HICKORY CREEK AT COLUMBUS (COLUMBUS, IN) has an overall 5-star rating, with strong quality measures and a 4-star health inspection rating, but a low 2-star staffing rating. Reported nurse staffing is 3.41 hours per resident per day, below the federal benchmark of 4.1, and there were $0 in fines in the last 24 months.
Last inspection: September 12, 2025Penalties, last 24 months: $0
Federal guidance recommends at least 4.1 nursing hours per resident each day. This facility reports 3.4074.
Staffing detail
Registered nurses
0.74
Licensed practical nurses
0.77
Nurse aides
1.90
Weekend nursing
3.06
Hours per resident per day.
Total staff turnover: 37%
Registered nurse turnover: 33%
Resident outcomes
Each measure compares a year ago with the most recent quarter. Green means the facility moved the right way; red means the wrong way.
Negative outcomes
Lower is better — fewer affected residents. A decrease is good (green); an increase is concerning (red).
Last yrNowTrend
Long-stay residents on antipsychotic medication
—4.5%—
Residents with a fall causing major injury
0%4.5%Worsening
Residents with pressure ulcers (bedsores)
2.9%3.9%Worsening
Residents with a urinary tract infection
0%0%No change
Residents who lost too much weight
0%5%Worsening
Residents who were physically restrained
0%0%No change
Residents needing more help with daily activities
—0%—
Residents whose ability to walk got worse
—3.2%—
Long-stay residents on antianxiety or sleep medication
47.8%45%Improving
Short-stay residents newly given an antipsychotic
—0%—
Residents with a long-term catheter
0%0%No change
Residents with new or worsening incontinence
9.2%5.2%Improving
Residents with depressive symptoms
16%9.5%Improving
Positive outcomes
Higher is better — e.g. vaccinations. An increase is good (green); a decrease is concerning (red).
Last yrNowTrend
Long-stay residents given the seasonal flu vaccine
—100%—
Long-stay residents given the pneumonia vaccine
100%100%No change
Short-stay residents given the seasonal flu vaccine
—93.1%—
Short-stay residents given the pneumonia vaccine
96.4%94.2%Worsening
What the inspectors found
The nursing home failed to develop and carry out a complete care plan that met each resident’s needs with clear steps and timelines. Cited September 2025 — isolated incident, potential for harm.
View the original federal record
F-Tag 656 — 42 CFR §483.21(b)(1) — S/S: D
The home failed to provide pharmacy services and a licensed pharmacist needed to meet each resident’s medication needs. Cited September 2025 — isolated incident, potential for harm.
View the original federal record
F-Tag 755 — 42 CFR §483.45 — S/S: D
The home failed to make sure food was safely sourced, stored, prepared, and served according to professional standards. Cited September 2025 — isolated incident, potential for harm.
View the original federal record
F-Tag 812 — 42 CFR §483.60(i) — S/S: D
The home failed to promptly tell the resident, doctor, and family about changes or problems affecting the resident. Cited August 2024 — isolated incident, potential for harm.
View the original federal record
F-Tag 580 — 42 CFR §483.10(g)(14) — S/S: D
The nursing home failed to provide appropriate treatment and care according to residents' orders, preferences, and goals. Cited August 2024 — isolated incident, potential for harm.
View the original federal record
F-Tag 684 — 42 CFR §483.25 — S/S: D
Recent history
STAFFING
Reported nurse staffing was below the federal recommendation of 4.1 hours per resident per day.
INSPECTION
Health inspection found 3 health deficiencies.
See what inspectors found
INSPECTION
Health inspection found 2 health deficiencies.
See what inspectors found
INSPECTION
Health inspection found 1 health deficiency.
See what inspectors found
Operator & ownership
Ownership
Government - County
Chain
Part of AMERICAN SENIOR COMMUNITIES · 91 homes · 4 stars avg
Occupancy
27.8 residents on an average day (77% of 36 beds)
Resident voice
Resident council
Medicare history
Certified for 34 years
Things at a nursing home change — inspections, staffing, ownership, news.
Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services — public records, updated monthly. GoodStanding presents official records with plain-language summaries. Always visit a facility in person.